Baseball Singles

Shop Baseball Singles at FanCave — graded and raw MLB cards including rookies, autographs, relics, vintage classics, and modern stars. Build sets, chase key players, or add investment pieces from Topps, Bowman, Panini, and more.

Our baseball singles inventory updates as new breaks and collections land in Kirkwood, MO, with competitive pricing and clear photos on every listing. Filter for your team, player, or grade and shop with confidence, with new arrivals added as product moves through the shop.

Browse Baseball Singles online for secure shipping from FanCave, or visit 121 N. Kirkwood Rd. for in-person picks. Authentic baseball card singles for collectors and fans of every MLB club. Fresh inventory from Fan Cave keeps this Baseball Singles collection worth checking often.

Willie Mays SGC 6 1958 Topps All-Star Card #486 - Front
Image alt
Willie Mays SGC 6 1958 Topps All-Star Card #486

$ 249.99

Out of stock
Willie Mays SGC 5.5 1958 Topps All-Star Card #486 - Front
Image alt
Willie Mays SGC 5.5 1958 Topps All-Star Card #486

$ 199.99

1 in stock
Hank Aaron SGC 4.5 1960 Topps Card #300 - Front
Image alt
Hank Aaron SGC 4.5 1960 Topps Card #300

$ 299.99

1 in stock
Hank Aaron SGC 4 1960 Topps Card #300 - Front
Image alt
Hank Aaron SGC 4 1960 Topps Card #300

$ 229.99

1 in stock
Brooks Robinson SGC 5.5 1959 Topps Card #439 - Front
Image alt
Brooks Robinson SGC 5.5 1959 Topps Card #439

$ 89.99

1 in stock
Brooks Robinson SGC 5 1959 Topps Card #439 - Front
Image alt
Brooks Robinson SGC 5 1959 Topps Card #439

$ 69.99

1 in stock
Brooks Robinson SGC 4 1958 Topps Card #307 - Front
Image alt
Brooks Robinson SGC 4 1958 Topps Card #307

$ 79.99

1 in stock
Yankees' Power Hitters SGC 2.5 1957 Topps Card #407 - Front
Image alt
Yankees' Power Hitters SGC 2.5 1957 Topps Card #407

$ 279.99

1 in stock
Yankees' Power Hitters SGC 2 1957 Topps Card #407 - Front
Image alt
Yankees' Power Hitters SGC 2 1957 Topps Card #407

$ 249.99

1 in stock
Yankees' Power Hitters SGC 1.5 1957 Topps Card #407 - Front
Image alt
Yankees' Power Hitters SGC 1.5 1957 Topps Card #407

$ 219.99

1 in stock
Ed Mathews SGC 2 1958 Topps Card #440 - Front
Image alt
Ed Mathews SGC 2 1958 Topps Card #440

$ 24.99

1 in stock
Ed Mathews SGC 4 1958 Topps Card #440 - Front
Image alt
Ed Mathews SGC 4 1958 Topps Card #440

$ 49.99

1 in stock
Mickey Mantle SGC 1.5 1958 Topps All-Star Card #487 - Front
Image alt
Mickey Mantle SGC 1.5 1958 Topps All-Star Card #487

$ 179.99

1 in stock
Mickey Mantle SGC 4 1958 Topps All-Star Card #487 - Front
Image alt
Mickey Mantle SGC 4 1958 Topps All-Star Card #487

$ 299.99

1 in stock
Mickey Mantle SGC 3 1958 Topps All-Star Card #487 - Front
Image alt
Mickey Mantle SGC 3 1958 Topps All-Star Card #487

$ 239.99

1 in stock
Mickey Mantle SGC 1 1953 Bowman Color Card #59 - Front
Image alt
Mickey Mantle SGC 1 1953 Bowman Color Card #59

$ 1,199.99

1 in stock
Shohei Ohtani PSA 9 2025 Topps Chrome X-Fractor Card #1 - Front
Image alt
Shohei Ohtani PSA 9 2025 Topps Chrome X-Fractor Card #1

$ 99.99

1 in stock
Kyle Schwarber PSA 9 2025 Topps Cosmic Chrome Green Space Dust #d/ 75 Card #13 - Front
Image alt
Kyle Schwarber PSA 9 2025 Topps Cosmic Chrome Green Space Dust #d/ 75 Card #13

$ 79.99

1 in stock
Nolan Ryan PSA 7 1979 Topps Card #115 - Front
Image alt
Nolan Ryan PSA 7 1979 Topps Card #115

$ 69.99

1 in stock
Shohei Ohtani PSA 10 2018 Panini Chronicles Classics Rookie RC Card #7 - Front
Image alt
Shohei Ohtani PSA 10 2018 Panini Chronicles Classics Rookie RC Card #7

$ 279.99

1 in stock
Bobby Witt Jr 2022 Topps Update Series Red Foil Rookie RC /199 Card #US100 - Front
Image alt
Bobby Witt Jr 2022 Topps Update Series Red Foil Rookie RC /199 Card #US100

$ 349.99

1 in stock
Misiorowski / Horton/ Lowder 2024 Topps Pro Debut Triple Autographs Rookie RC /25 Card #PDTA-MHL - Front
Image alt
Misiorowski / Horton/ Lowder 2024 Topps Pro Debut Triple Autographs Rookie RC /25 Card #PDTA-MHL

$ 499.99

1 in stock
Shohei Ohtani 2019 Topps Update Series 1984 Topps Baseball Blue Rookie RC Error Card #84-25 - Front
Image alt
Shohei Ohtani 2019 Topps Update Series 1984 Topps Baseball Blue Rookie RC Error Card #84-25

$ 449.99

1 in stock
Shohei Ohtani 2019 Topps Baseball Series One 1984 Baseball Relics Game Used Memorabilia /150 Card #84R-SO - Front
Image alt
Shohei Ohtani 2019 Topps Baseball Series One 1984 Baseball Relics Game Used Memorabilia /150 Card #84R-SO

$ 229.99

1 in stock
Yoshinobu Yamamoto 2026 Topps Chrome Purple Refractor - Image Variation /75 Card #75 - Front
Image alt
Yoshinobu Yamamoto 2026 Topps Chrome Purple Refractor - Image Variation /75 Card #75

$ 249.99

1 in stock
Mookie Betts PSA 10 2025 Topps Chrome Ultra Violet All Stars Case Hit Card #UV6 - Front
Image alt
Mookie Betts PSA 10 2025 Topps Chrome Ultra Violet All Stars Case Hit Card #UV6

$ 139.99

1 in stock
Bobby Witt Jr PSA 10 2022 Topps Chrome Update Purple Refractor Rookie RC Card #USC35 - Front
Image alt
Bobby Witt Jr PSA 10 2022 Topps Chrome Update Purple Refractor Rookie RC Card #USC35

$ 299.99

1 in stock
Fernando Tatis Jr PSA 10 2020 Topps SSP Card #168 - Front
Image alt
Fernando Tatis Jr PSA 10 2020 Topps SSP Card #168

$ 349.99

1 in stock
Wyatt Langford PSA 9 2025 Topps Museum Collection Archival Autograph /149 Card #WL - Front
Image alt
Wyatt Langford PSA 9 2025 Topps Museum Collection Archival Autograph /149 Card #WL

$ 39.99

1 in stock
Heinie Wagner SGC A 1910 Sweet Caporal Bat On Left Shoulder Card #T206 - Front
Image alt
Heinie Wagner SGC A 1910 Sweet Caporal Bat On Left Shoulder Card #T206

$ 89.99

1 in stock

Showing 60/71

Explore Related Products

Shohei Ohtani PSA 9 2025 Bowman's Best Blue Lazer #d/150 Card #46 - Front
Image alt
Topps
Shohei Ohtani PSA 9 2025 Bowman's Best Blue Lazer #d/150 Card #46

$ 129.99

1 in stock
Banks/ Guerrero/ Jones/ McMillon PSA 10 1996 Topps Prospects Card #435 - Front
Image alt
Topps
Banks/ Guerrero/ Jones/ McMillon PSA 10 1996 Topps Prospects Card #435

$ 79.99

1 in stock
Upton/ Ohtani/ Trout PSA 10 2018 Topps Now Rookie RC Card #OD182 - Front
Image alt
Topps
Upton/ Ohtani/ Trout PSA 10 2018 Topps Now Rookie RC Card #OD182

$ 139.99

Out of stock
Max Clark PSA 9 2024 Bowman's Best - Best of 2024 Autograph Refractor Card #B24MC - Front
Image alt
Topps
Max Clark PSA 9 2024 Bowman's Best - Best of 2024 Autograph Refractor Card #B24MC

$ 129.99

1 in stock
Jackson Chourio PSA 9 2025 Topps Finest Moments Autograph Card #FMAJCH - Front
Image alt
Topps
Jackson Chourio PSA 9 2025 Topps Finest Moments Autograph Card #FMAJCH

$ 99.99

Out of stock
Shohei Ohtani PSA 9 2025 Topps Murakami Tokyo Series Card #25 - Front
Image alt
Topps
Shohei Ohtani PSA 9 2025 Topps Murakami Tokyo Series Card #25

$ 149.99

1 in stock