Sell to Us

We buy sports cards and collectibles. Tell us what you have, send a few photos, and we'll get back to you with a quote. Get paid in cash, or choose store credit, which comes with an incentive.

Start your quote

What We Buy?

  • Graded Cards
  • Ungraded Cards
  • Sealed Wax & Cases
  • Pokémon ProductsRaw (ungraded) Pokémon is only bought when Joey is in. Call (636) 778-3848 first to make sure he's available.
  • MemorabiliaWe're selective. Must be authenticated by a reputable third-party authentication company.
  • Full CollectionsNo collection is too small or too large. From a single box to hundreds, we'd love the chance to make you an offer.

We usually pass on bulk commons and other low-demand items, but if you're not sure, ask. We're happy to take a look.

How it works

  1. Send us the detailsFill out the form below, then text photos to (636) 778-3848 or email help@fancave.com.
  2. Get a quoteWe'll get back to you as quickly as we can.
  3. Bring it in or ship itBring your items to our Kirkwood store or ship them in. Walk-ins are welcome during card buying hours.

Tell us what you're selling

Photos: after you submit, take photos of the front and back and text them to (636) 778-3848 or email help@fancave.com.

Selling FAQ

How do you decide what to pay?

It depends on the card. We look at condition and recent market sales for the same item, so every offer is different.

How do I get paid?

You can take cash, or choose store credit, which comes with an incentive.

Do I need an appointment?

No. Walk-ins are welcome during card buying hours. For bigger collections, sending details through the form first helps us get ready for you. Selling raw (ungraded) Pokémon? We only buy it when Joey is in, so call (636) 778-3848 first to make sure he's available.

Do you buy memorabilia?

Yes, but we're very selective. Memorabilia must be authenticated by a reputable third-party authentication company.

Do you buy whole collections?

Yes. Send us an overview through the form, then text some photos to (636) 778-3848 or email help@fancave.com, and we'll get back to you.

Questions?

Call (636) 778-3848 or email help@fancave.com.

Sell locally in Kirkwood

Fan Cave is your local card shop at 121 N. Kirkwood Rd, Kirkwood, MO 63122. Bring your collection in and talk cards with collectors who know the hobby.

Card Buying Hours

Tuesday - Thursday: 11am - 7pm
Friday: 11am - 8pm
Saturday: 11am - 8pm
Sunday: 11am - 5pm

Get directions